The Interaction of Biological Factors with Mechanical Signals in Bone Adaptation: Recent Developments

Mechanotransduction in bone is fundamental to proper skeletal development. Deficiencies in signaling mechanisms that transduce physical forces to effector cells can have severe consequences for skeletal integrity. Therefore, a solid understanding of the cellular and molecular components of mechanotransduction is crucial for correcting skeletal modeling and remodeling errors and designing effective therapies. In recent years, progress has been made on many fronts regarding our understanding of bone cell mechanotransduction, including subcellular localization of mechanosensitive components in bone cells, the discovery of mechanosensitive G-protein- coupled receptors, identification of new ion channels and larger pores (eg, hemichannels) involved in physical signal transduction, and cell adhesion proteins, among others. These and other recent mechanisms are reviewed to provide a synthesis of recent experimental findings, in the larger context of whole bone adaptation

WNT-mediated Modulation of Bone Metabolism: Implications for WNT Targeting to Treat Extraskeletal Disorders

The WNT-signaling pathway is involved in cellular and tissue functions that control such diverse processes as body axis patterning, cellular proliferation, differentiation, and life span. The long list of molecules that can participate or modify WNT signaling makes this pathway one of the most complex in cell biology. In bone tissues, WNT signaling is required for proper skeletal development, and human mutations in various components of the cascade revealed insights into pharmacologic targeting that can be harnessed to improve skeletal health. In particular, mutations in genes that code for the WNT-signaling inhibitor sclerostin or the WNT coreceptor lipoprotein receptor-related protein 5 have highlighted the potential therapeutic value of recapitulating those effects in patients with low bone mass. A constant challenge in this area is selectively modifying WNT components in the tissue of interest, as WNT has manifold effects in nearly every tissue

New Insights into Wnt-Lrp5/6-β-Catenin Signaling in Mechanotransduction

Mechanical loading is essential to maintain normal bone metabolism and the balance between bone formation and resorption. The cellular mechanisms that control mechanotransduction are not fully defined, but several key pathways have been identified. We discuss the roles of several components of the Wnt signaling cascade, namely Lrp5, Lrp6, and β-catenin in mechanical loading-induced bone formation. Lrp5 is an important Wnt co-receptor for regulating bone mass and mechanotransduction, and appears to function principally by augmenting bone formation. Lrp6 also regulates bone mass but its action might involve resorption as well as formation. The role of Lrp6 in mechanotransduction is unclear. Studies addressing the role of β-catenin in bone metabolism and mechanotransduction highlight the uncertainties in downstream modulators of Lrp5 and Lrp6. Taken together, these data indicate that mechanical loading might affect bone regulation triggering the canonical Wnt signaling (and perhaps other pathways) not only via Lrp5 but also via Lrp6. Further work is needed to clarify the role of the Wnt signaling pathway in Lrp5 and/or Lrp6-mediated mechanotransduction, which could eventually lead to powerful therapeutic agents that might mimic the anabolic effects of mechanical stimulation

Skeletal loading in animals

A number of in vivo skeletal loading models have been developed to test specific hypotheses addressing the key mechanical and biochemical signals involved in bone’s adaptive response to loading. Exercise protocols, osteotomy procedures, loading of surgically implanted pins, and force application through the soft tissues are common approaches to alter the mechanical environment of a bone. Although each animal overload model has a number of assets and limitations, models employing extrinsic forces allow greater control of the mechanical environment. Sham controls, for both surgical intervention (when performed) and loading, are required to unequivocally demonstrate that responses to loading are mechanically adaptive. Collectively, extrinsic loading models have fostered a greater understanding of the mechanical signals important for stimulating bone cells, and highlighted the roles of key signaling molecules in the adaptive response

Improving bone properties and fracture susceptibility: experimental models of genetic manipulation, pharmacologic intervention, and cellular perturbation reveal new approaches for improving bone health

poster abstractBone, a crucial support structure in the human body, is often taken for granted for its lightweight properties and unparalleled strength. Skeletal fracture is a major clinical condition affecting millions of Americans, which results from abnormal aging, hormonal imbalance, genetic conditions, and lifestyle choices (e.g., exercise). Because fractures are caused by a number of different factors, reducing fracture incidence requires a multifactorial approach to unraveling the underlying biology of bone metabolism, in order to discover new ways to improve bone properties and prevent fractures. We have taken such an approach by conducting (1) genetic manipulation experiments in mice, where genes predicted to be involved in bone mass regulation were mutated; (2) pharmacologic experiments to quantify the dose-response effect of an agent that inhibits bone loss, and (3) cell culture experiments, aimed at revealing molecular pathways activated by mechanical stimulation. METHODS: Mice with mutations in two genes, likely to regulate bone mass (SOST, DKK1) were generated and subjected to in vivo dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scans at 6-wk old. Whole body scans were analyzed for bone mineral density (BMD) using Lunar Piximus II v2.10 software. Mice (6-wk) were also dosed (0, 1, 10, 100, or 1000 mg/kg) with daily alendronate HCl, a bisphosphonate that inhibits osteoclast activity. Six wks later, the mice were sacrificed, and the femurs were dissected and sectioned for histological analysis of bone formation parameters, including mineralizing surface (MS/BS), mineral apposition rate (MAR), and bone formation rate (BFR/BS). To understand the cellular signaling events in response to mechanical loading, bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) were treated with 10, 20, 30, or 40μM PF7408671, an S6 kinase inhibitor. Cells then were subject to 100 cycles of biaxial mechanical strain (2%, 10 cycles/min). Protein lysates were separated by electrophoresis and probed for phosphorylation of Rictor and Akt by Western blot. RESULTS: Mice harboring mutations in either the SOST gene or the DKK1gene exhibited significantly increased BMD compared to wild-type control mice, though the SOST mutation had a stronger effect on BMD than DKK1. Mice with compound mutations (SOST and DKK1 mutations) had significantly greater BMD than mice with either single mutation, suggesting that inhibition of SOST and DKK1 might be an effective means to increase bone mass in patients susceptible to fracture. Mice treated with high-dose alendronate (100 or 1,000 mg/kg) exhibited significant decreases in bone formation parameters (MS/BS, MAR, and BFR/BS) compared to untreated (0 mg) mice, suggesting that while this compound might be beneficial for inhibiting bone loss, it also inhibits bone formation. The signaling hub, mTORC2, is a critical regulator of mechanical force in MSC progenitors. Our data demonstrate that S6 kinase is an upstream activator of mTORC2 in response to mechanical strain. CONCLUSION: Our experiments suggest that genetic manipulation of mice reveal viable protein targets (e.g., SOST, DKK1) that could ultimately be manipulated pharmacologically to improve bone mass. We also found that an FDA-approved class of drugs inhibits bone formation even at very low doses, suggesting that additional pro-anabolic compounds might benefit patients taking bisphosphonates. On a cell signaling level, we found that the mTORC2 pathway shows considerable promise for pharmacologic manipulation to simulate the effects of exercise. Taken together, these experiments highlight the utility of a broad approach to solving bone metabolism challenges that can affect fracture susceptibility

Nmp4/CIZ suppresses the response of bone to anabolic parathyroid hormone by regulating both osteoblasts and osteoclasts

How parathyroid hormone (PTH) increases bone mass is unclear, but understanding this phenomenon is significant to the improvement of osteoporosis therapy. Nmp4/CIZ is a nucleocytoplasmic shuttling transcriptional repressor that suppresses PTH-induced osteoblast gene expression and hormone-stimulated gains in murine femoral trabecular bone. To further characterize Nmp4/CIZ suppression of hormone-mediated bone growth, we treated 10-week-old Nmp4-knockout (KO) and wild-type (WT) mice with intermittent human PTH(1–34) at 30 μg/kg daily or vehicle, 7 days/week, for 2, 3, or 7 weeks. Null mice treated with hormone (7 weeks) gained more vertebral and tibial cancellous bone than WT animals, paralleling the exaggerated response in the femur. Interestingly, Nmp4/CIZ suppression of this hormone-stimulated bone formation was not apparent during the first 2 weeks of treatment. Consistent with the null mice enhanced PTH-stimulated addition of trabecular bone, these animals exhibited an augmented hormone-induced increase in serum osteocalcin 3 weeks into treatment. Unexpectedly, the Nmp4-KO mice displayed an osteoclast phenotype. Serum C-terminal telopeptide, a marker for bone resorption, was elevated in the null mice, irrespective of treatment. Nmp4-KO bone marrow cultures produced more osteoclasts, which exhibited elevated resorbing activity, compared to WT cultures. The expression of several genes critical to the development of both osteoblasts and osteoclasts was elevated in Nmp4-KO mice at 2 weeks, but not 3 weeks, of hormone exposure. We propose that Nmp4/CIZ dampens PTH-induced improvement of trabecular bone throughout the skeleton by transiently suppressing hormone-stimulated increases in the expression of proteins key to the required enhanced activity and number of both osteoblasts and osteoclasts

High-bone-mass causing mutant LRP5 receptors are resistant to endogenous inhibitors in vivo

Certain missense mutations affecting LRP5 cause high bone mass (HBM) in humans. Based on in vitro evidence, HBM LRP5 receptors are thought to exert their effects by providing resistance to binding/inhibition of secreted LRP5 inhibitors such as sclerostin (SOST) and Dickkopf homolog-1 (DKK1). We previously reported the creation of two Lrp5 HBM knock-in mouse models, in which the human p.A214V or p.G171V missense mutations were knocked into the endogenous Lrp5 locus. To determine whether HBM knock-in mice are resistant to SOST- or DKK1-induced osteopenia, we bred Lrp5 HBM mice with transgenic mice that overexpress human SOST in osteocytes ((8kb) Dmp1-SOST) or mouse DKK1 in osteoblasts and osteocytes ((2.3kb) Col1a1-Dkk1). We observed that the (8kb) Dmp1-SOST transgene significantly lowered whole-body bone mineral density (BMD), bone mineral content (BMC), femoral and vertebral trabecular bone volume fraction (BV/TV), and periosteal bone-formation rate (BFR) in wild-type mice but not in mice with Lrp5 p.G171V and p.A214V alleles. The (2.3kb) Col1a1-Dkk1 transgene significantly lowered whole-body BMD, BMC, and vertebral BV/TV in wild-type mice and affected p.A214V mice more than p.G171V mice. These in vivo data support in vitro studies regarding the mechanism of HBM-causing mutations, and imply that HBM LRP5 receptors differ in their relative sensitivity to inhibition by SOST and DKK1

Finite Element Analysis of the Mouse Proximal Ulna in Response to Elbow Loading

Bone is a mechano-sensitive tissue that alters its structure and properties in response to mechanical loading. We have previously shown that application of lateral dynamic loads to a synovial joint, such as the knee and elbow, suppresses degradation of cartilage and prevents bone loss in arthritis and postmenopausal mouse models, respectively. While loading effects on pathophysiology have been reported, mechanical effects on the loaded joint are not fully understood. Because the direction of joint loading is non-axial, not commonly observed in daily activities, strain distributions in the laterally loaded joint are of great interest. Using elbow loading, we herein characterized mechanical responses in the loaded ulna focusing on the distribution of compressive strain. In response to 1-N peak-to-peak loads, which elevate bone mineral density and bone volume in the proximal ulna in vivo, we conducted finite-element analysis and evaluated strain magnitude in three loading conditions. The results revealed that strain of ~ 1000 μstrain (equivalent to 0.1% compression) or above was observed in the limited region near the loading site, indicating that the minimum effective strain for bone formation is smaller with elbow loading than axial loading. Calcein staining indicated that elbow loading increased bone formation in the regions predicted to undergo higher strain

Clcn7F318L/+ as a new mouse model of Albers-Schönberg disease

Dominant negative mutations in CLCN7, which encodes a homodimeric chloride channel needed for matrix acidification by osteoclasts, cause Albers-Schönberg disease (also known as autosomal dominant osteopetrosis type 2). More than 25 different CLCN7 mutations have been identified in patients affected with Albers-Schönberg disease, but only one mutation (Clcn7G213R) has been introduced in mice to create an animal model of this disease. Here we describe a mouse with a different osteopetrosis-causing mutation (Clcn7F318L). Compared to Clcn7+/+ mice, 12-week-old Clcn7F318L/+ mice have significantly increased trabecular bone volume, consistent with Clcn7F318L acting as a dominant negative mutation. Clcn7F318L/F318L and Clcn7F318L/G213R mice die by 1 month of age and resemble Clcn7 knockout mice, which indicate that p.F318L mutant protein is non-functional and p.F318L and p.G213R mutant proteins do not complement one another. Since it has been reported that treatment with interferon gamma (IFN-G) improves bone properties in Clcn7G213R/+ mice, we treated Clcn7F318L/+ mice with IFN-G and observed a decrease in osteoclast number and mineral apposition rate, but no overall improvement in bone properties. Our results suggest that the benefits of IFN-G therapy in patients with Albers-Schönberg disease may be mutation-specific