Family physicians' experiences when collaborating with district nurses in home care-based medical treatment. A grounded theory study

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>This article concerns Swedish family physicians' (FPs) experiences collaborating with district nurses (DNs) when the DNs provide medical treatment for home care patients. The aim was to develop a model to illuminate this process from the FPs' perspective.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 13 FPs concerning one of their patients with home care by a DN. The interview focused on one patient's treatment and care by different care providers and the collaboration among them. Grounded theory methodology (GTM) was used in the analyses.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>It was essential for FPs to collaborate with and rely on DNs in the medical treatment of home care patients. According to the FPs, factors such as the disease, FPs' working conditions and attitude determined how much of the initiative in this treatment FPs retained or left to DNs. Depending on the circumstances, two different roles were adopted by the individual FPs: <it>medical conductors </it>who retain the initiative and <it>medical consultants </it>who leave the initiative to DNs. Factors as the disease, DNs' attitudes towards collaboration and DNs' working conditions influenced whether or not the FPs felt that grounds for relying on DNs were satisfactory. Regardless of the role of the FP, conditions for medical treatment were judged by the FPs to be good enough when the grounds for relying on the DN were satisfactory and problematic when they were not.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p>In the role of conductor, the FP will identify when the grounds for relying on the DN are unsatisfactory and be able to take action, but in the role of consultant the FP will not detect this, leaving home care patients without appropriate support. Only when there are satisfactory grounds for relying on the DN, will conditions for providing home care medical treatment be good enough when the FP adopts a consultative role.</p

Family physicians' effort to stay in charge of the medical treatment when patients have home care by district nurses. A grounded theory study

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>District nurses (DNs) provide home care for old persons with a mixture of chronic diseases, symptoms and reduced functional ability. Family physicians (FPs) have been criticised for their lack of involvement in this care. The aim of this study was to obtain increased knowledge concerning the FP's experience of providing medical treatment for patients with home care provided by DNs by developing a theoretical model that elucidates how FPs handle the problems they encounter regarding the individual patients and their conditions.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 13 Swedish FPs concerning one of their registered patients with home care by a DN, and the treatment of this patient. Grounded theory methodology (GTM) was used in the analyses.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>The core category was the effort to stay in charge of the medical treatment. This involved three types of problems: gaining sufficient insight, making adequate decisions, and maintaining appropriate medical treatment. For three categories of patients, the FPs had problems staying in charge. Patients with reduced functional ability had problems providing information and maintaining treatment. Patients who were "fixed in their ways" did not provide information and did not comply with recommendations, and for patients with complex conditions, making adequate decisions could be problematic. To overcome the problems, four different strategies were used: relying on information from others, supporting close observation and follow-up by others, being constantly ready to change the goal of the treatment, and relying on others to provide treatment.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>The patients in this study differed from most other patients seen at the healthcare centre as the consultation with the patient could not provide the usual foundation for decisions concerning medical treatment. Information from and collaboration with the DN and other home care providers was essential for the FP's effort to stay in charge of the medical treatment. The complexity of the situation made it problematic for the FP to make adequate decisions about the goal of the medical treatment. The goal of the treatment had to be constantly evaluated based on information from the DN and other care providers, and thus this information was absolutely crucial.</p

Characteristics and trends in required home care by GPs in Austria: diseases and functional status of patients

BACKGROUND: Almost all societies carry responsibility towards patients who require continuous medical care at home. In many health systems the general practitioner cooperates with community based services of home care and coordinates all medical and non medical activities. In Austria the general practitioner together and in cooperation with relatives of the patient and professional organisations usually takes on this task by visiting his patients. This study was carried out to identify diseases that need home care and to describe the functional profile of home care patients in eastern Austria. METHODS: Cross sectional observational study with 17 GP practices participating during 2 study periods in 1997 and in 2004 in eastern Austria. Each GP identified patients requiring home care and assessed their underlying diseases and functional status by filling in a questionnaire personally after an encounter. Patients in nursing homes were excluded. Statistical tests used were t-tests, contingency tables, nonparametric Wilcoxon signed rank sum test and Fisher-combination test. RESULTS: Patients with degenerative diseases of the central nervous system (65%) caused by Alzheimer's disease and cerebrovascular occlusive disease and patients with degenerative diseases of the skeletal system (53%) were the largest groups among the 198 (1997) and 261 (2004) home care cases of the 11 (1997) and 13 (2004) practices. Malignant diseases in a terminal state constituted only 5% of the cases. More than two thirds of all cases were female with an average age of 80 years. Slightly more than 70% of the patients were at least partially mobile. CONCLUSION: Home care and home visits for patients with degenerative diseases of the central nervous and skeletal system are important elements of GP's work. Further research should therefore focus on effective methods of training and rehabilitation to better the mental and physical status of patients living in their private homes

The medical treatment of patients with home care by district nurses from the family physician s perspective

Background and aim: The aim of this thesis has been to shed light on home care patients, their problems and comprehensive care, and the family physicians experiences of providing medical treatment for home care patients. Material and methods: One quantitative study (resulting in two articles) from a suburban city area in 1996 concerning one third of the patients receiving home care by district nurses (DNs) (n=116). Information on the patients, their problems and comprehensive care was collected from several sources. One qualitative study used grounded theory methodology (GTM) (resulting in two articles). Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 13 Swedish FPs concerning one of their patients with home care by a DN, and the treatment of this patient. Results: A typical patient with home care by DNs was an older single woman with multiple diseases and functional problems. Many care providers were involved in her comprehensive care including both home help staff and hospitals. Several different physicians were often involved. The patients usually visited the FP at the health centre (HC) on average twice a year, but not all patients visited their FP in a year. Many FPs measures were undertaken without a visit. The patients problems influenced the FP s ability to remain in charge of the medical treatment. Patients with reduced functional ability and patients who wanted to manage on their own did not provide information and many could not handle their own treatment. FPs had to rely on the DNs, who saw the patients on average once a week or every other week, for information and help with home care medical treatment. When patients had complex conditions or did not comply with recommendations it was hard to make adequate decisions on the goal of the medical treatment. FPs had to rely on close observation and follow-up by the DNs for information as a basis for constant evaluation of the goal. The DNs working conditions, attitudes and the type of disease the patient had determined whether or not the grounds for relying on the DNs were adequate. The FPs took either the role of a medical conductor, retaining the initiative in the medical treatment, or the role of a medical consultant, leaving the initiative to the DNs. One FP could take different roles in different situations. Which role the FP chose or was forced to take depended on their working conditions, attitude and the type of disease. Conditions for providing home care medical treatment are good enough when there are adequate grounds for relying on the DNs and problematic when there aren t, regardless of the role taken by the FP. Conclusion: Due to the problems of home care patients, FPs consultations with the patient cannot provide the usual foundation for medical decisions. They have to be able to rely on information and collaboration with the DNs in home care medical treatment, much like the collaboration in a hospital ward. As conductors, FPs detect when conditions are problematic and when no adequate grounds for relying on the DN exist. As consultants, however, they will not detect inadequate grounds as they will receive little or no information from the DNs. In order to stay in charge of the medical treatment as consultants, the FPs working conditions must allow them to know if adequate grounds for relying on the DNs exist. The FPs working conditions must also allow them to be conductors when necessary. The comprehensive care of home care patients includes many different care providers, just like a hospital ward, but without its geographical, organisational and temporal unity. Time and routines to support collaboration is needed and all care providers need to know when they are responsible

Primary care patients with mild or stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease need more support in disease management : a secondary analysis of a cluster randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE: Patient education based on the patient's individual needs and circumstances is known to be associated with positive changes in clinical outcomes in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). We aimed to assess the levels of patients' subjective needs for information about COPD before and after their general practitioners had taken part in a COPD education. DESIGN: A secondary analysis of a cluster randomized controlled trial. SETTING: 22 PHCCs in Stockholm, Sweden. SUBJECTS: Randomly selected primary care patients with COPD in GOLD stages 2 and 3 (n = 293). OUTCOME MEASURES: Scores in the Lung Information Needs Questionnaire (LINQ) at baseline and 18 months, spirometry results, and self-reported, descriptive patient data. RESULTS: GPs' improved skills in COPD did not affect patients' self-management skills over time. In general, patients' information needs remained great in issues concerning diet, exercise and self-management. However, 43% of the patients reported reduced and 57% increased or unchanged information needs, over time. Reduced information needs were mainly associated with a high level of information needs at baseline (OR = 3.17 [95% CI 1.93-5.23], p &lt; .01) and establishing contact with a physiotherapist (OR = 2.26 [95% CI 1.05-4.86], p = .038). Patients in a mild or stable phase of COPD with no recent exacerbations reported greater needs than those with unstable, deteriorated COPD. CONCLUSION: Patients' information needs are substantial in most areas of self-management of COPD, and seem to covary with the patient's current clinical status. Care providers should thus continuously be vigilant about offering all patients with COPD support and education. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinicaltrials.gov, 10 August 2014, Identifier NCT02213809

COPD patients need more information about self-management : a cross-sectional study in Swedish primary care

Objective: In Sweden, patients with chronic conditions, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), often receive education at specialized nurse-led clinics at primary health care centers (PHCCs). Identifying patients' needs for information about COPD is the key to individualized care. This study aimed to assess self-reported needs for information about COPD in primary care patients with either moderate (GOLD 2) or severe (GOLD 3) COPD and identify patient characteristics and exacerbation patterns associated with the findings. Design: A cross-sectional study. Setting: Twenty-four PHCCs in Stockholm, Sweden. Subjects: Randomly selected primary care patients with COPD in GOLD stages 2 and 3 (n = 542). Main outcome measures: The Lung Information Needs Questionnaire (LINQ) was used to assess perceived information needs. Spirometry results and descriptive, self-reported data on patient factors such as exacerbation history, treatment, smoking, weight/height, comorbidities, health care contacts, education and symptoms were collected. Results: Overall, the greatest reported needs were for information about self-management and diet. GOLD 2 patients (68%) expressed greater needs for information than GOLD 3 patients (32%). We found significant associations between high information needs and patient-related factors such as 'No assigned GP' (OR = 4.32 [95% CI 2.65-7.05]) and 'No contact with COPD nurse in the past 12 months' (OR = 1.83 [95% CI 1.19-2.81]). Conclusion: COPD patients felt they knew too little about self-management of their disease. Low information needs were strongly associated with continuity in patient-GP consultations and moderately associated with contact with a COPD nurse. These associations were strongest in patients with moderate COPD